Head to head · Utility

John Deere 5105 vs Massey Ferguson 451

Image not recorded
John DeereModel A

John Deere 5105

Utility

power
45.6 hp
displacement
179 ci
Cylinders
3
Forward gears
8
Full 5105 specs
Image not recorded
Massey FergusonModel B

Massey Ferguson 451

Utility

power
52 hp
displacement
201 ci
Cylinders
3
Forward gears
8
Full 451 specs
John DeereJohn Deere 5105
vs
Massey FergusonMassey Ferguson 451

How they compare

Headline specs vs. the whole Utility

n = 1,083–5,720

Engine Power

▲ 451 higher · +6.4 hp (+14%)
510545.6 hp
45152 hp
Median Utility Tractor55 hp

5105 is in the 40th percentile; 451 is in the 47th · 5,383 models

Engine Displacement

▲ 451 higher · +22 ci (+12%)
5105179 ci
451201 ci
Median Utility Tractor183 ci

5105 is in the 48th percentile; 451 is in the 54th · 5,580 models

Cylinders

= Effectively tied
51053
4513
Median Utility Tractor4

5105 is in the 23rd percentile; 451 is in the 23rd · 5,720 models

Forward Gears

= Effectively tied
51058
4518
Median Utility Tractor12

5105 is in the 23rd percentile; 451 is in the 23rd · 4,941 models

5105 (A)451 (B)Median Utility Tractor

Full comparison

Every spec, side by side

General Information

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
ManufacturerJohn DeereMassey Ferguson—
Model5105451—
CategoryUtilityUtilitySame

Engine

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
ManufacturerJohn DeerePerkins—
Model3029D1103C-33—
Power Output45.6hp52hp▲ 451+6.4 hp · +14%
Rated RPM2,300RPM2,200RPM▲ 5105+100 RPM · +5%
Cylinders33Same
Displacement179ci201ci▲ 451+22 ci · +12%
Bore4.2in4.1in▲ 5105+0.1 in · +2%
Stroke4.3in5in▲ 451+0.7 in · +16%

Transmission

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
TypePartially synchronized with dry disc clutchGear type with dry disc clutch—

Dimensions & Weight

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
Length109in135in▲ 451+26 in · +24%
Width68.9in71.7in▲ 451+2.8 in · +4%
Height90.2in96.5in▲ 451+6.3 in · +7%
Operating Weight4,125lb4,740lb▲ 451+615 lb · +15%

Hydraulics

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
System TypeOpen centerOpen centerSame
Steering TypeHydrostatic powerPower—

Power Take-off (PTO)

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
TypeIndependentRear: Live or independent—
Speed 1540rpm540rpmSame

Hitch & Towing

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
Hitch TypeThree-Point HitchNot recorded—
Hitch CategoryII/III/ISame
Hitch PositionRearNot recorded—
Hitch Capacity3,000lb2,425lb▲ 5105+575 lb · +24%

Chassis & Drive

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
Chassis Type4x2 2WDNot recorded—
Drive Type2WD2WDSame
Steering TypeHydrostatic powerPower—
Brake TypeDifferential mechanical wet discIndependent wet disc—

Electrical

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
Starter TypeElectricElectricSame

Capacities

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
Coolant2.5galNot recorded—

Operator Station

SpecJohn Deere 5105Massey Ferguson 451Difference
TypeOpen operator station with two-post ROPSFlat-deck platform with two-post folding ROPS—

Category context

Both models against the field

Engine Power

median 55 hp
A · 40th percentile (45.6 hp)B · 47th percentile (52 hp)

Engine Displacement

median 183 ci
A · 48th percentile (179 ci)B · 54th percentile (201 ci)

Cylinders

median 4
A · 23rd percentile (3)B · 23rd percentile (3)

Forward Gears

median 12
A · 23rd percentile (8)B · 23rd percentile (8)

Operating Weight

median 5,303 lb
A · 39th percentile (4,125 lb)B · 45th percentile (4,740 lb)
A · 5105B · 451Median Utility Tractor
Full spec pageJohn Deere 5105Full spec pageMassey Ferguson 451